Highly
Skilled Migrants vindicated by landmark judgment from UK High Court
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Highly Skilled Migrants
in UK have finally been vindicated in their belief that justice would
prevail despite of sustained unfair and discriminatory treatment by
Immigration Ministry. UK High Court, in its landmark judgment, has ruled
that the Judicial Review application filed by HSMP Forum Limited against
unfair retrospective changes to Highly Skilled Migrant Programme (HSMP)
in November 2006 has been successful.
Immigration Ministry had introduced a new Point Based System in November
2006 and had retrospectively imposed it on the Highly Skilled Migrants
who had entered UK as per earlier Scheme offered to them. Approximately
49,000 migrants and their families entered the scheme between January
2002 and November 2006. High Court judgement confirmed the various
appeals made by Highly Skilled Migrants, in its judgement stating “the
old scheme constituted an integrated and entire programme and that it
was not open to the government to alter the terms and conditions upon
which the pre-arranged stages were to be implemented.”
It is
noteworthy that Highly Skilled Migrant Programme was introduced in 2002
with the aim to provide an individual migration route for highly skilled
persons who have the skills and experience required by the United
Kingdom to compete in the global economy. It is ironical that the UK
government chose to play tough with the very category of migrants who
are making valuable contribution to the economy without using public
funds and have made a commitment to make UK their main home.
Amit
Kapadia, Executive Director of HSMP Forum
expressed his satisfaction over the outcome of legal proceedings,
initiated only after all other avenues for a positive resolution were
exhausted. He said with a sigh of relief “The unfair and retrospective
element of changes to extension criteria of HSMP were highlighted by the
Highly Skilled Migrants through their MPs, a petition was handed over to
the Prime Minister, a meeting was held with the Immigration Minister in
the House of Commons. Presentations were made by several MPs across
party lines. Joint Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights as well as
Commission for Racial
Equality
had
looked into the issue and submitted to the government that the changes
were unfair and unlawful. However, the immigration department was
obsessed with defending their decision and were not open to any
reasoning. We had no other recourse but to approach the judiciary and we
are glad that our trust in the Democratic System has finally been
restored.”
Baskaran Kumarasamy, Executive Committee Member of HSMP Forum
said
“UK High
Court judgement reflects the feelings expressed by thousands of Highly
Skilled Migrants and their family members.”
Justice Sir George Newman,
in his landmark judgement observes “In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the terms of
the original scheme should be honoured and that there is no good reason
why those already on the scheme shall not enjoy the benefits of it as
originally offered to them. Good administration and straightforward
dealing with the public require it. Not to restrain the impact of the
changes would, in my judgment, give rise to conspicuous unfairness and
an abuse of power.”
The retrospective changes have been declared Unlawful and Home Office
was refused permission to appeal to Court of Appeal by Justice Newman!!
Court Order
"It is ordered and declared that this claim be allowed and that
the defendant (Secretary of State for the Home Department) has acted
unlawfully in applying H.C. 1702 Rule 135D to persons already admitted
to the Highly Skilled Migrants Scheme as at the 7th day of November
2006." |